[야야]네이쳐에 실린 한국인 논문 표절 기사 :: 2008/10/10 02:02
하하하하~~~
기사 원문은 http://www.nature.com/news/2008/081008/full/455715a.html?s=news_rss
프로그램으로 잡아보니 문장들이 85% 이상 동일한게 181 편. 그 중에서 한 사례가 소개되었는데 그게 한국인 논문.
When Eric Le Bourg, a French biogerontologist, came across a paper in a Korean journal recently, he almost fell off his chair; the entire article — text and graphs included — had been taken from one of his earlier articles. "It was plagiarism from beginning to end," he says. "I was astonished; it was pure cut and paste."
...
Le Bourg's paper, "A review of the effects of microgravity and hypergravity on aging and longevity" was published in the Elsevier journal, Experimental Gerontology (E. Le Bourg Exp. Gerontol. 34, 319–336; 1999). The duplicate, by Hak-Ryul Kim, who listed his affiliation as the biology department of Korea University in Seoul, was published a year later in the Korean Journal of Biological Sciences (H.-R. Kim Kor. J. Biol. Sci. 4, 231–237; 2008).
(->표절 논문 정보가 잘못되었음. 2008년이라고 나와 있는데 2000년임)
Le Bourg and the editors of Experimental Gerontology have tried to investigate further, but to no avail. They contacted authorities at Korea University but got no response, Le Bourg says. E-mails to Kim were not returned. He seems to have left the university, says Bourg, who hasn't been able to track down Kim's current affiliation. Meanwhile, the Korean Journal of Biological Sciences has ceased publication.
이름은 Hak-Ryul Kim, 논문 출판 당시 소속은 Korea University in Seoul.
표절 논문은 http://www.koreascience.or.kr/article/articleresultdetail.jsp?no=36448453&searchtype=JSB&listlen=14&listno=4
원 논문은 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10433387
제가 있는 곳에서는 원본이 열리질 않아서 직접 확인해보진 못했습니다만... 프로그램으로 잡아낸 결과 유사도가 73%라는군요.
한국인 저자들의 논문 중 표절로 분류된 것들 목록은 http://spore.swmed.edu/dejavu/duplicate/?duplication_type__id__exact=2&ot=desc&pmid2__ref__Address__icontains=korea&o=7
요기서 보시면 됩니다. 자기 논문 좀 바꿔서 한두달 만에 다른 저널에 또 낸 경우들도 수두룩. 자기복제. 유사도 93%로 일등인 사람도 자기 복제. 남 논문 복제율 1위는 위의 논문. 남 논문 복제 2, 3위는 Seoul National University와 Yonsei University 소속. 자랑스런 SKY 다 걸렸구나. http://spore.swmed.edu/dejavu/reference/5951/ 이거 하고 http://spore.swmed.edu/dejavu/reference/10183/ 이거.
지화자~ 연구실 동료들한테 자랑(?)하고 다녔음. 개망신. ㅡ,.ㅡ
